Simpliers lets you draw from up to 200 entries free once per post with no login, on public Instagram accounts and on X, TikTok and YouTube. CommentsPickerPro’s free account picks an instant winner from the first page of comments; its paid side adds Facebook Pages to a 5-platform pool, shows the collected count beside the platform’s own number, and can be paid per platform or with comment credits that never expire instead of a subscription.
CommentsPickerPro
YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, X (Twitter).
Simpliers
Instagram, X (Twitter), TikTok and YouTube; Facebook appears in its menu.
CommentsPickerPro
Free account, no credit card. Instant random winner from the first page of comments on a post, with a daily pick limit.
Simpliers
Up to 200 entries per giveaway, free once per post.
CommentsPickerPro
Free account. YouTube connects with Google; Instagram needs your Business or Creator account; TikTok and X need only the link.
Simpliers
No login required; the Instagram account must be public.
CommentsPickerPro
À la carte: pay per platform you use, plus optional credits (500 comments each, never expire). Current rates on the pricing page.
Simpliers
Subscription: $19.90 a month, or $9.99 a month billed yearly ($119.90), up to 40,000 entries. A single-credit option is listed.
CommentsPickerPro
Up to 6 posts across all 5 platforms in one pool, one draw (Premium).
Simpliers
Combines multiple posts and multiple platforms into one giveaway.
CommentsPickerPro
Collected count shown beside the platform’s own comment count; every comment readable before the draw.
Simpliers
Not stated on their page.
CommentsPickerPro
Cryptographic randomness; paid draws get a seed and a public winner certificate.
Simpliers
Verifiable validity certificate with a giveaway code and a public results page.
CommentsPickerPro
Duplicates, keywords/hashtags, required @mentions, minimum length, blocked words (paid).
Simpliers
Unique users, minimum tag count and word filters.
CommentsPickerPro
Comments and winners to CSV, JSON or TXT (paid).
Simpliers
Participants to XLS / Excel.
CommentsPickerPro
Nine animations with a full-screen live mode.
Simpliers
Not compared here.
| CommentsPickerPro | Simpliers (simpliers.com) | |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, X (Twitter). | Instagram, X (Twitter), TikTok and YouTube; Facebook appears in its menu. |
| Free tier | Free account, no credit card. Instant random winner from the first page of comments on a post, with a daily pick limit. | Up to 200 entries per giveaway, free once per post. |
| Account needed | Free account. YouTube connects with Google; Instagram needs your Business or Creator account; TikTok and X need only the link. | No login required; the Instagram account must be public. |
| Paid model | À la carte: pay per platform you use, plus optional credits (500 comments each, never expire). Current rates on the pricing page. | Subscription: $19.90 a month, or $9.99 a month billed yearly ($119.90), up to 40,000 entries. A single-credit option is listed. |
| Several posts / platforms in one draw | Up to 6 posts across all 5 platforms in one pool, one draw (Premium). | Combines multiple posts and multiple platforms into one giveaway. |
| Count check | Collected count shown beside the platform’s own comment count; every comment readable before the draw. | Not stated on their page. |
| Proof of the winner | Cryptographic randomness; paid draws get a seed and a public winner certificate. | Verifiable validity certificate with a giveaway code and a public results page. |
| Entry filters | Duplicates, keywords/hashtags, required @mentions, minimum length, blocked words (paid). | Unique users, minimum tag count and word filters. |
| Export | Comments and winners to CSV, JSON or TXT (paid). | Participants to XLS / Excel. |
| Winner reveal | Nine animations with a full-screen live mode. | Not compared here. |
Simpliers facts are taken from its own pages on 8 November 2026: simpliers.com/, simpliers.com/en/giveaway/instagram, simpliers.com/en/giveaway/prices. Prices and limits change; check their site before you decide.
Both have a free option. Simpliers states up to 200 entries free once per post with no login. CommentsPickerPro’s free account picks an instant winner from the first page of comments, with a daily limit.
CommentsPickerPro supports Facebook posts from Pages you manage, alongside YouTube, Instagram, TikTok and X. Simpliers lists Instagram, X, TikTok and YouTube on its prices page, with Facebook in its menu.
Simpliers lists monthly and yearly subscriptions. CommentsPickerPro also sells comment credits (500 comments each) that never expire, so an occasional giveaway does not need a monthly plan.
Yes. Simpliers issues a validity certificate with a giveaway code. CommentsPickerPro uses cryptographic randomness and gives paid draws a seed and a public certificate.